Boyle came to West Virginia as a part of the 2023 recruiting class and was viewed as a bit of a late bloomer in the recruiting process. At Charlotte Catholic High School in North Carolina, Boyle played in a completely different style of offense and had to adjust to a more spread out attack in Morgantown. He did, however, throw for 1,941 yards, 20 touchdowns, and three picks while completing 68% of his passes as a senior.

Boyle chose West Virginia over offers from Arkansas State, Charlotte, Connecticut, James Madison, Memphis, Rutgers, South Florida, and a few others. He will have four years of eligibility remaining.