Nathan Cleary set to play again this year as Panthers get positive news about injured halfback
The Penrith Panthers have provided a positive update on Nathan Cleary’s latest injury, revealing the champion halfback won’t require surgery despite dislocating his shoulder on Thursday night. Cleary was forced to leave the field in the second half of Penrith’s 24-22 loss to the Melbourne Storm, and underwent scans on Friday to assess the extent of the damage.
The scans only revealed minor damage, and Cleary won’t need surgery to fix the issue. Cleary suffered a dislocation/instability issue, which occurred during a tackle with Josh King, and he appeared devastated in the dressing rooms after the game as he cut a forlorn figure with heavy ice packs on his left shoulder.
It’s the other shoulder to the one he damaged in 2021, when he had a stint on the sidelines before playing through the pain to win the grand final. He eventually had to undergo surgery in the off-season, and it’s looking like a similar scenario in 2024.
In a startling revelation, coach Ivan Cleary said his son had aggravated an injury that had been troubling him since the pre-season. “I’m concerned,” Ivan said in his press conference. “It was bad enough for him to come off. We’ll organise the scans tomorrow, until we get those, we’ll be in a better position to see our way forward.”
According the ‘NRL Physio’ Brien Seeney, a shoulder dislocation isn’t a disastrous outcome for Cleary and the Panthers. With only minor damage, Cleary might miss just two games and could be ready for the start of the NRL finals in three weeks’ time. On Friday, the Panthers said their plan is to have him ready to play at some stage in the finals as they seek a fourth-straight NRL title.
With three games remaining until the NRL finals, Panthers fans will be hoping the damage is only minor and Cleary can make it back for the playoffs. It’s been a turbulent year for the champion halfback, who suffered a hamstring injury in Round 3 and then aggravated it in Round 10 in just his second game back.
He spent 10 weeks on the sidelines getting his hamstring right before returning last month, only to do his shoulder on Thursday night. “He’s in better shape than he was when he did his hammy. Hopefully that means it’s good news,” Ivan Cleary said. “What do you do? It’s just one of those years.”
“It just means there’s going to have to be individuals who step up. But it certainly hasn’t been new this season. [Cleary] is the most diligent man I know, in terms of that, the confidence will be sky-high, he’ll tick every box for sure.”
Panthers legend Greg Alexander said in commentary for Fox League: “He would be devastated. Not knowing the seriousness of it but it certainly didn’t look good and there was very limited movement in that arm when he left the field, he was keeping it very still. So you would think he’s dislocated it, whether it’s popped back in itself, which it can do, or they had to put it back in which wouldn’t be a good situation.”
Former Lions star Mitch Robinson says he and his family will never go to a Brisbane game again after they were denied entry to his old club’s dressing rooms on Saturday night. Robinson – who played for both Carlton and Brisbane before hanging the boots up in 2022 – watched as the Lions blew the Blues off the park.
Brisbane were incredibly impressive registering a 28-point victory on Saturday night after running out to a huge 60-0 lead in the second term. And wanting to celebrate with his former teammates after the match Robinson went down to the changerooms but he claims he was turned away. Feeling hurt and cheated, the 35-year-old took to X to voice his displeasure.
“Imagine playing and bleeding for a club for eight years, copping copious amounts of head knocks and staples in my face (long-term effects) just to have my family turned away to come down to the rooms after the game to celebrate with my old teammates,” he wrote on X, in a since-deleted post.
“Football is a fake family, just remember that. I’ll never go to a Lions game again.”
However, Brisbane has communicated that Robinson was denied entry by Gabba security staff because he did not have the required accreditation. But the club says he was then issued an accreditation pass by a member of the footy department when it became known he had not been let in. Robinson is understood to have then turned down the offer when a group of friends he was with were denied entry.
Mitch Robinson’s AFL career ended in messy fashion
Robinson had earlier shared photos of him in Lions gear with AFL great Brendan Fevola. And multiple posts on social media depict him supporting Brisbane in several previous matches.
But after being turned away, Robinson says he will not go to another game. The latest development comes after Robinson also shared his disappointment at the way his career ended in Brisbane.
The 35-year-old was delisted at the end of 2022 and no rival club made a move for him, ultimately resulting in Robinson deciding to call time on his career. His tenure at the Lions ended messily after he was denied an opportunity for his retirement to be celebrated by fans and teammates.
Robinson said Lions coach Chris Fagan made it clear that his retirement needed to remain a closely guarded secret heading into the club’s preliminary final loss. And Robinson then went public with his displeasure with his former coach.
“Devastated Fages (Chris Fagan) wouldn’t allow me to announce this in person to the supporters and my teammates, but I guess that’s footy,” he posted. “It’s been an absolute privilege pulling on the Fitzroy and Lions jumper!”
Robinson said he has since fallen out of love with the sport and told SEN radio earlier this year that the handling of his retirement played a major part in that. “That was probably the start of it,” he said.
“The way that all happened and went down was obviously a kick in the nuts and that’s when I was like, you know what, it’s a business, it’s footy, the game that you love. I did fall out of love with the game for about two years before I finished, even though we were successful and doing well, the only thing I loved was game day.” The Lions will play Greater Western Sydney in Saturday’s semi-final, with the prize an MCG preliminary final date with Geelong.
Wayne Bennett‘s Souths rebuild continues to take shape with the Rabbitohs announcing the departure of seven players. Despite Bennett still being in charge of the Dolphins, since agreeing to return to Souths next year as head coach, the super coach has continued to pull strings behind the scenes at Redfern.
After a horror 2024 campaign, Souths need some serious change and fast. Bennett has already signed off on deals to bring Dolphins duo Euan Aitken and Lachlan Hubner with him to Redfern in 2025. And he has also given the all-clear on signings Gerome Burns, Lewis Dodd (St Helens Saints), Jamie Humphreys (Sea Eagles), and Max McCarthy (Sharks) for next season.
However, as well as bringing in some much-needed reinforcements, the Bunnies have also cleared some of their unwanted playing stocks. Veterans Damien Cook (Dragons) and Tom Burgess (Huddersfield) were told to seek pastures new and have signed deals elsewhere. And on Sunday it was announced halfbacks Dean Hawkins and Dion Teaupa, winger Izaac Thompson and forwards Leon Te Hau and Michael Chee-Kam will also be following them out the door.
Chee Kam is reportedly set to join NRL rivals the Sea Eagles, while Hawkins is reportedly in talks with the Eels and Titans. However, Teaupa, Thompson or Te Hau are understood to not have been contacted by any other NRL clubs at this time and find themselves without a club at this stage for 2025.
But Bennett may not be done swinging the axe just yet, with multiple players on Souths’ top 30 roster still unsigned for 2025. The likes of Ben Lovett, Isaiah Tass, Shaquai Mitchell and Taane Milne are all without deals for next year but are not confirmed departures. It is understood there are offers on the table for Tass and Milne but no contract as yet has been offered to Lovett or Milne.
Ben Hornby says Souths will bounce back in a big way in 2025
South Sydney interim coach Ben Hornby believes the Bunnies will bounce back in a big way in 2025. Despite a disastrous season that saw them finish second last after losing seven-straight games to round out the season, Hornby believes the club has the personnel to turn things around next season.
The Rabbitohs have had a very disjointed 2024 campaign, with coach Jason Demetriou sacked just weeks into the season and the club also having to manage without several stars who were sidelined for extended periods. Campbell Graham, Jai Arrow, Junior Tatola and Latrell Mitchell have all spent many weeks out of the side, taking the wind out of their season.
“The ladder is usually pretty fair after the 27 rounds, so we can’t really argue with that,” Hornby said following Souths’ 36-28 defeat to finish the season. “I think you’ve seen that we’ve put in a lot of good efforts. When we had a side that was close to doing what we were capable of, we were winning games.
“Next year, I can’t see why if we’re not somewhere near our full-strength side that we won’t be winning games. We’ve got a lot of really, really good players missing at the moment, so if we get those guys back and do the right thing, the wins will take care of themselves.”
A frustrated Wayne Bennett has renewed calls to scrap the bunker review system after Trai Fuller was denied a try in the 14-6 loss to Newcastle that ended the Dolphins’ NRL finals hopes.
Mature-age rookie Fuller darted over on the left side midway through the first half to score what appeared the opening try of Sunday’s shootout for eighth spot at McDonald Jones Stadium.
But on closer inspection, the bunker ruled Dolphins second-rower Connelly Lemuelu had impacted the outside shoulder of Knights forward Brodie Jones and prevented him from reaching Fuller.
Newcastle ran in the next two tries and ultimately clinched the last spot in the top eight, crushing the Dolphins’ hopes of a maiden finals berth in their second season.
Lemuelu had also contacted Jack Cogger with his run but impacted only the Knights’ five-eighth’s inside shoulder – not grounds for an obstruction because his passage to the ball had not been blocked.
At full-time, Benett suggested it was Cogger who had actually obstructed Jones and not Lemuelu, furious that the try had not stood.